Let’s chat →

Home Loans & Property

What is a "loyalty tax”, and how can I avoid paying it?

What is a "loyalty tax”, and how can I avoid paying it?

Director & Head of Finance

Updated

4 min read

The short answer

Imagine that you’ve been a loyal customer of a lender for many years, getting charged a certain interest rate on your home loan. Then, you find that your lender has been offering new customers much better rates whilst slowly increasing the mortgage rate on your home loan. If it sounds like this migh

In short: The "loyalty tax" is the higher rate many lenders charge existing customers compared with new ones. To avoid it, compare your rate with your lender's new-customer rate every year or two, ask for a match, and refinance if they will not. On a $500,000 loan, a 1% higher rate costs about $300 a month.

Imagine that you’ve been a loyal customer of a lender for many years, getting charged a certain interest rate on your home loan. Then, you find that your lender has been offering new customers much better rates whilst slowly increasing the mortgage rate on your home loan. If it sounds like this might be unfair, you aren’t alone.

Similar scenarios unfold daily at banks and lenders across Australia. In the mortgage broking industry, it’s referred to as the loyalty tax.

What is a "loyalty tax" in Australia?

Loyalty tax is the premium interest rate you pay for being loyal to a lender.

This refers to when lenders reserve their lower interest rates for their newest customers whilst older customers are stuck with rates that slowly creep up. This is because lenders know that many borrowers will accept the rate of their current loan, whilst better deals are needed to entice potential customers to their business.

Research from the RBA has found that the difference between new and old interest rates increases throughout the length of the home loan. This means that the longer you stay on your home loan, the higher your ‘loyalty tax’ may be.

How do I know if I'm paying a loyalty tax on my current home loan?

Even if you have only been with your current lender for a couple of years, you may be paying a loyalty tax. This will be particularly relevant for borrowers on a variable-rate home loan.

Luckily, it’s easy to find out if you’re paying a premium interest rate. Through your lender, find the rates currently offered to new customers and compare them with your own. If there is a significant difference between the two, you’re likely paying a loyalty tax.

How do I avoid paying a loyalty tax on my home loan?

Before you panic and switch lenders, you should first get in touch with your current lender and ask them to review your home loan. If you’ve found better deals offered to new customers and from other lenders, you’ll be able to make a strong case for yourself.

In the finance industry, the squeaky wheel gets the grease. Lenders want to keep your business and will often agree to a reduced interest rate or risk losing you as a customer. This is where using a mortgage broker will be crucial. A good mortgage broker will use their negotiating skills and finance expertise to facilitate the best possible deal for your mortgage.

If your lender is unwilling to offer a better rate on your home loan, don’t be afraid to switch your home loan to a lender that will.

How much can refinancing save me?

Of course, this will depend on your individual circumstances.

The Australian Competition & Consumer Commission's 2020 home loan price inquiry found that the average gap between rates on new and existing loans grows with the age of the loan:

  • 0.29% difference on loans less than one-year-old

  • 0.47% difference on loans between one and three years old

  • 0.58% difference on loans between three and five years old

  • 0.71% difference on loans between five and ten years old

  • 1.04% difference on loans more than ten years old

Bar graph displaying the escalating gap in interest rates between new and old home loans

What would this mean for your repayments? On a $500,000 loan with 20 years remaining, paying 7.04% instead of 6% would add about $306 a month, or around $3,700 a year (figures illustrative).

If you want to find out how much a lower rate could save you, use our free refinancing calculator to compare different rates and refinancing options.

Why don’t customers refinance more often?

The biggest reason is the most obvious one; refinancing can be a hassle. Maybe it's just easier to stay with your existing lender and not worry about your home loan terms? Sadly, this is what lenders are banking on, and it’s the reason why so many borrowers get stuck paying excessive interest costs.

Using a mortgage broker is a great way to deal with this problem. A mortgage broker can handle all of the paperwork, negotiating, and bank jargon for you - plus their services likely won’t cost you a thing!

Don’t be scared of refinancing; it could save you thousands from loyalty taxes.

In fact, we recommend that our clients review their interest rate every couple of years to ensure they are still getting the best deal on the market.

Unlike the process of purchasing a home, refinancing is a far less daunting experience. Without needing to deal with solicitors and real estate agents, you can let your lender and mortgage broker do the legwork for you.

If you are thinking about refinancing, talk to Elephant Advisory’s mortgage brokers. We are required by law to act in your best interests.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if I am paying a loyalty tax?

Compare your current rate with the rate your lender advertises to new customers for the same loan type and loan-to-value ratio. A gap of more than about 0.25% is worth acting on.

Will my bank lower my rate if I ask?

Often, yes, especially if you show a competing offer and have a good repayment history. Ask for the retention team.

How often should I review my home loan rate?

At least every one to two years, and whenever rates change or your loan-to-value ratio improves.

Last updated: 25 October 2026.

General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, so consider whether it is appropriate for you and seek personal advice before acting. Elephant Financial Pty Ltd trading as Elephant Advisory is an authorised credit representative (ACR 487962) of Yellow Brick Road Aggregation Pty Ltd (formerly Vow Financial Pty Ltd) (ABN 66 138 789 161), Australian Credit Licence 390261.

Free calculatorCould you save by refinancing?Your monthly saving at a lower rate, and how fast the switching costs pay for themselves.
Open calculator
Author photo

Written by

Director & Head of Finance

Gav is the person you want in your corner when it comes to property finance. After years in banking and motor trade finance, he joined Elephant early and never looked back. He's passionate about combining property and finance to help clients achieve their goals through tailored financial structuring, and he's very serious about snacks at meetings.

Gavin Hepponstall

Need advice on this?

Talk to our team, it’s free.

Book a free chat

Want this sorted for your business?

Want this sorted for your business?

Your accountant, bookkeeper and broker in one team that talks to each other.

Let’s chat

Elephant Financial Pty Ltd (ABN 38 611 576 240) trading as Elephant Advisory is an authorised credit representative (ACR 487962) of Yellow Brick Road Aggregation Pty Ltd (formerly Vow Financial Pty Ltd) (ABN 66 138 789 161), Australian Credit Licence 390261. Accounting and tax services are provided by Elephant Tax Pty Ltd (ABN 39 626 563 755), bookkeeping by Elephant Bookkeeping Pty Ltd (ABN 49 682 979 139), digital marketing by Elephant Digital Pty Ltd (ABN 72 692 273 091) and offshore staffing by Elephant Teams Pty Ltd (ABN 24 656 874 789). The ultimate holding company is Elephant Ventures Pty Ltd (ABN 86 660 006 771).

Elephant Financial Pty Ltd (ABN 38 611 576 240) trading as Elephant Advisory is an authorised credit representative (ACR 487962) of Yellow Brick Road Aggregation Pty Ltd (formerly Vow Financial Pty Ltd) (ABN 66 138 789 161), Australian Credit Licence 390261. Accounting and tax services are provided by Elephant Tax Pty Ltd (ABN 39 626 563 755), bookkeeping by Elephant Bookkeeping Pty Ltd (ABN 49 682 979 139), digital marketing by Elephant Digital Pty Ltd (ABN 72 692 273 091) and offshore staffing by Elephant Teams Pty Ltd (ABN 24 656 874 789). The ultimate holding company is Elephant Ventures Pty Ltd (ABN 86 660 006 771).

Elephant Financial Pty Ltd (ABN 38 611 576 240) trading as Elephant Advisory is an authorised credit representative (ACR 487962) of Yellow Brick Road Aggregation Pty Ltd (formerly Vow Financial Pty Ltd) (ABN 66 138 789 161), Australian Credit Licence 390261. Accounting and tax services are provided by Elephant Tax Pty Ltd (ABN 39 626 563 755), bookkeeping by Elephant Bookkeeping Pty Ltd (ABN 49 682 979 139), digital marketing by Elephant Digital Pty Ltd (ABN 72 692 273 091) and offshore staffing by Elephant Teams Pty Ltd (ABN 24 656 874 789). The ultimate holding company is Elephant Ventures Pty Ltd (ABN 86 660 006 771).